Coca-Cola drops AI-made holiday TV ads a year after calling them top-tested
Coca-Cola's 2026 holiday TV ads were filmed, not AI-generated. A year ago it called its AI ad a top tester. It gives no reason, score or cost.
At a glance
- Company
- The Coca-Cola Company · Retail and consumer · Size not stated
- Team and use case
- Marketing · Content production (holiday TV advertising)
- Tools
- Silverside AI (studio, 2025 ad), Secret Level (studio, 2025 ad)
- Stage
- Paused or rolled back, since AI holiday ads in 2024 and 2025; filmed spots November 2026
- Results
- Lead holiday TV ad: AI-generated (2024, 2025) → Filmed (2026)
- Pre-launch consumer testing of the AI ad: "Top-tested" (company, 2025); no score
- Sales or sentiment effect of the AI ads: Not disclosed
- Cost
- Not disclosed for the AI ads or the filmed ones.
- People
- In 2025 the central generative AI team was two people, with colleagues elsewhere giving 40% to 50% of their time; three studios made the 2024 film. The 2026 spots had a director and a production company. What changed for the AI team: not disclosed.
- Evidence
- Company claim, no method
The company states a result without saying how it was measured.
What this leaves out: The move away from AI is Marketing Dive's description from campaign details Coca-Cola shared; the company gave no reason. The test results are executives' statements with no scores, and nothing shows what the AI ads did to sales.
Coca-Cola's marketing team launched its 2026 holiday campaign on 19 November with TV spots that "pivot away from using generative artificial intelligence as the brand did for recent holiday pushes", [Marketing Dive reported](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/coca-cola-pivots-from-divisive-ai-generated-ads-for-holiday-campaign/875215/) from details the company shared. The "Enjoy Joy" ads show families playing football and deep-frying a turkey; they were directed by Paul Dektor, produced by Mayan Productions, created by WPP Open X and led by Ogilvy. In 2024 and 2025 the brand's lead holiday ad, "Holidays Are Coming", was made with generative AI (software that produces video from written instructions).
What Coca-Cola said a year ago
When the 2025 version drew a second year of criticism, Islam ElDessouky, global vice president for creative strategy and content, [told Marketing Dive](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/why-coca-cola-keeps-pushing-limits-generative-ai-despite-backlash/804739/): "this is one of our top-tested ads in history, period." He added: "We're going to keep going at it, to be honest with you, because it's giving us the measurements, the metrics and the business results." The 2025 ad was a "refreshed and optimized version" of the 2024 one, made with the studios Silverside AI and Secret Level, [according to the launch report](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/coca-cola-doubles-down-ai-new-holiday-campaign/804303/).
The testing behind that claim was described in [a March 2025 interview](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/what-coca-cola-learned-generative-ai/741709/) by Pratik Thakar, Coca-Cola's head of generative AI. Three studios made three versions of the 2024 film. Coca-Cola researched them with "at least three different research agencies" in North America, Europe and Latin America, and the ad "passed our own and competitions' Christmas ad benchmarks". He also said: "Some consumers loved it, a lot of people didn't like it."
The people and the catch
Coca-Cola has not said why it changed. The statement Marketing Dive quotes, from Stacy Jackson, vice president for the Coca-Cola Trademark, does not mention AI; it speaks of "staying true to what people have always loved about the brand". Marketing Dive's own description is that the earlier ads "proved divisive with consumers" despite exceeding internal benchmarks. The report does not say whether AI is still used in the campaign's digital and social content or in production work the viewer never sees.
No number is public on either side: no test score, no sales or sentiment figure, no cost for the AI films or the filmed ones. On people, Thakar said in 2025 that the central generative AI team was two people, with colleagues in other units giving 40% to 50% of their time, and that people made many of the creative decisions and composed the music. What happened to that work this year is not stated.
Coca-Cola is not alone this season. Levi's and e.l.f. ran stop-motion holiday ads, and Gartner analyst Emily Weiss told [Marketing Dive](https://www.marketingdive.com/news/holiday-marketing-hits-inflection-point-in-2026-what-brands-need-to-know/874758/) that consumers have shown resistance to AI-made marketing materials, while Gartner research finds over a third very or extremely willing to use AI tools for holiday shopping.
Reading this at work? Get one story like it explained every morning.
A five-minute read every morning at 7am ET: one story explained, two in brief, what else happened, one number. Unsubscribe in one click.
What to do if you run marketing
- Before an AI-generated asset leads a campaign, agree in writing which signal would pull it (pre-launch test, sentiment after launch, or sales) and who makes the call. By its own account, Coca-Cola's pre-launch tests passed.
- Split AI in your plan into two lines: work the audience never sees (versions, localisation, research) and AI as the visible look of the ad. The controversy Marketing Dive describes was over a visibly AI-generated film.
- Ask your agency to price the same brief both ways, generated and filmed, with timelines. Coca-Cola has published neither, so there is no benchmark to borrow.
Take this to work
Forward this
Coca-Cola's 2026 holiday TV ads move away from the generative AI it used in 2024 and 2025, a year after an executive called the AI ad "one of our top-tested ads in history" (Marketing Dive, 19 November 2026); the company gives no reason, score or cost. Before AI-generated creative fronts one of our campaigns, we should agree which result would make us pull it and who decides.
Questions to ask
- What did our pre-launch test measure, and would it have caught a public reaction to how the ad was made rather than to its story?
- What does the same brief cost generated and filmed, including agency time, and how long does each take?
- Who signs off AI-generated creative before it goes out, and who decides to withdraw it once it is live?
- Where is AI used in our campaigns out of the audience's sight, and would we keep that if the visible use stopped?
Questions this article answers
Is Coca-Cola's 2026 Christmas ad made with AI?
Marketing Dive reported on 19 November 2026 that the "Enjoy Joy" TV spots pivot away from the generative AI used in recent years; they were directed by Paul Dektor and produced by Mayan Productions. The report does not say whether AI is used elsewhere in the campaign.
Why did Coca-Cola stop using AI in its holiday ads?
Coca-Cola has given no reason. Its statement does not mention AI, and Marketing Dive describes the 2024 and 2025 AI ads as divisive with consumers despite exceeding internal benchmarks.
How did Coca-Cola's AI holiday ads perform?
In November 2025 Coca-Cola's Islam ElDessouky called the ad "one of our top-tested ads in history", and in March 2025 Pratik Thakar said it passed the company's and competitors' Christmas ad benchmarks. No score, sales figure or cost has been published.
Jumia cut about 260 jobs in six months and credits AI; no cost or split
Jumia's filings show payroll down from about 1,980 to 1,720 since March, credited to AI automation. Before you copy the plan, ask for the split by team.
Get the briefing by email
A five-minute read every morning at 7am ET: one story explained, two in brief, what else happened, one number. Unsubscribe in one click.