NewsFor: HR and recruiting · Legal and compliance

University of Kentucky excused an employee from AI on religious grounds

A research administrator won a religious exemption from using AI at work. HR teams with an AI mandate need a route for these requests first.

The University of Kentucky has excused a research administrator from using AI at work as a religious accommodation, [HR Dive reported on 2 November 2026](https://www.hrdive.com/news/kentucky-college-grants-religious-accommodation-excusing-humanist-from-ai/873491/). The employee is a humanist. The American Humanist Association announced the decision on 26 October and said the university granted the request in late September, after its equal opportunity office concluded that his not using AI placed no undue burden on his department.

The university confirmed the outline. Spokesperson Jay Blanton told HR Dive by email that it reviews such requests one at a time and concluded the employee could perform the essential functions of his job with the accommodation. He added a condition: "As technology and job responsibilities evolve, accommodations may be reviewed to ensure they remain reasonable and workable."

What he objected to

The employee said using AI "violates my deeply held Humanist beliefs which demand I take personal responsibility for the morality of my actions", according to the association's release as quoted by HR Dive. He cited AI's environmental costs, its "interference with people's ability to earn a living" and its "supplanting and theft of human creativity".

He is not the first. A software engineer in North Carolina, a Unitarian Universalist, asked her employer for an exemption in April 2026 on environmental and ethical grounds and received it in mid-May, [Business Insider reported in June](https://www.businessinsider.com/worker-got-religious-exemption-using-ai-at-work-2026-6) after seeing the email. She works for what the report calls a large tech-entertainment company, which it does not name, and now writes and reviews code by hand.

Why an employer cannot wave it away

US federal law (Title VII of the Civil Rights Act) requires an employer to accommodate a religious belief or practice unless that causes undue hardship. Since the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy, hardship means "a burden is substantial in the overall context of an employer's business"; a cost that is merely more than trivial no longer suffices, [the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says](https://www.eeoc.gov/religious-discrimination). The commission's page says the law covers people with "sincerely held religious, ethical or moral beliefs", not only members of organised religions.

The belief does not need a church behind it. Employment lawyers [told HR Dive in May 2026](https://www.hrdive.com/news/ai-mandates-may-stir-up-religious-objections-hr-should-prepare-now/818857/) that courts and the commission rarely question sincerity, and pointed to EEOC v. Consol Energy: a West Virginia coal miner objected on religious grounds to a biometric hand scanner used for clocking in, lost his job, and was awarded more than half a million dollars. An alternative way to record his hours would have settled it, James Paul of the law firm Ogletree Deakins told the publication.

The catch

  • Two cases, no court ruling. Both employers said yes, so no judge has decided when declining to use AI becomes an undue hardship. "If you're encountering this, there's a good chance you might be the test case," Evan Peña of the law firm Quarles & Brady told HR Dive.
  • The answer depends on the job. Kentucky found a research administrator could do his without AI. Neither report says what happens when AI is built into the system a role runs on, such as a support desk where an assistant drafts every reply.
  • Not disclosed: which AI tools the university expects staff to use, whether it requires AI use at all, how the employee's work is checked now, or what the accommodation costs his department.
  • This is US law. Neither report covers other countries.

What to do if your company requires AI use

  • HR: add one line to the AI-use policy saying where a request for exemption on grounds of belief goes, and make it the existing religious accommodation process. Tell managers not to rule on such a request, or on whether the belief is real, themselves.
  • HR with legal: for each role covered by the mandate, write down whether the work can be done without the AI tool and what the alternative is. That record is the hardship analysis; Kentucky's turned on "essential functions".
  • People who set AI-usage targets: check how you have treated staff who simply do not use the tools. If they do their jobs without trouble, a jury will look at that when you say an exemption is a hardship, Peña told HR Dive.
Was this useful for your work?

Take this to work

Forward this

The University of Kentucky granted an employee a religious accommodation in late September 2026 excusing him from using AI at work, HR Dive reports, at least the second such US case reported this year. If we require AI use, we should route these requests through our existing religious accommodation process and record, role by role, whether the job can be done without the tool.

Questions to ask

  1. Does our AI-use policy say where a request for exemption on grounds of belief goes, and do managers know not to decide it themselves?
  2. For which roles is the AI tool part of the system the job runs on, so that opting out means changing the job?
  3. How have we treated people who do not use the AI tools for non-religious reasons, and are they meeting their targets?
  4. Do our AI-usage dashboards or performance goals penalise someone who holds an approved exemption?

Questions this article answers

Can an employee refuse to use AI at work for religious reasons?

In the US an employee can ask for a religious accommodation, and the employer must grant it unless it causes undue hardship, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says. The University of Kentucky granted one to a humanist research administrator in late September 2026, HR Dive reports.

What counts as undue hardship for a religious accommodation?

Since the Supreme Court's 2023 decision in Groff v. DeJoy, a burden must be substantial in the overall context of the employer's business, taking into account its nature, size and operating cost, according to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Does the belief have to come from an organised religion?

No. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says the law also protects people with sincerely held religious, ethical or moral beliefs. The Kentucky employee is a humanist; the earlier North Carolina case involved a Unitarian Universalist.

Send this to someone who runs a teamLinkedInXBlueskyHNEmail