West Midlands Police switched off Copilot after an invented football match reached an official report
West Midlands Police, England's third-largest force, switched off staff access to Microsoft Copilot in January 2026 after a football match that never took place appeared in a report it gave to the panel that barred away fans from a game in Birmingham. The force's report of 24 October 2025 cited a West Ham United match against Maccabi Tel Aviv on 9 November 2023. "There was no such fixture," the chief inspector of constabulary wrote to the Home Secretary on 14 January 2026. A force interviewee told inspectors the line "was the result of a search the force carried out using Microsoft Copilot" and called it "an AI hallucination", the letter says.
Why it matters: The chief constable, Craig Guildford, told a committee of MPs on 6 January that officers had found the material through a Google search. "We do not use AI," he said, according to The Register. On 12 January he wrote to the committee that the error came from Copilot, and on 16 January he retired. That is 10 days. MPs stopped short of saying he deliberately misled them, The Register reported on 24 February: he had not been told before the hearing, although the AI use had already been disclosed inside the force. Anyone who signs a statement to a regulator, an auditor or a customer about how a document was produced sits in the same seat.
The catch: The inspectorate's main finding is confirmation bias, not software. Its letter says the officer responsible for intelligence on the operation was not involved in preparing the report, and that inspectors saw no notes made at the time for a number of key documents. The Copilot account rests on one interviewee. On 26 August 2026 the Independent Office for Police Conduct said Guildford, three officers and a staff member are under investigation; those are allegations, not findings. No source says what was typed into Copilot, how many staff had it or what the episode cost.
What to do: Ask your IT lead this week for a list of every AI tool staff can reach on work devices, including the assistants built into search and office software. For any document going to a regulator, court, board or auditor, require a line saying which statements came from an AI tool and who checked each against an original record. Before anyone signs or testifies that AI was not used, ask the people who did the research, in writing, and keep the reply.
Looking ahead: Acting chief constable Scott Green said on 27 January that the force will use Copilot again once it has "broader policy and guidelines in place", The Register reported. None of these sources says whether it is back on.
Our coverage →HMICFRS letter to the Home Secretary on West Midlands Police and safety advisory groups (14 Jan 2026) ↗Independent Office for Police Conduct: update on Maccabi Tel Aviv supporter ban investigation (26 Aug 2026) ↗The Register: West Midlands Police chief retires after Copilot output used in fan ban (19 Jan 2026) ↗The Register: West Midlands Police suspends Copilot after hallucinated match (28 Jan 2026) ↗The Register: Home Affairs Committee findings on West Midlands Police and Copilot (24 Feb 2026) ↗